I'm Broken
by @johnstaples
Liner Notes
In my notebook I keep random sad lines and verse/chorus snippets. Today I decided to stitch a bunch of them together into a song!
As I usually do, I got the lyrics into pretty good shape so they were singable. Then I worked out a tricky verse/chorus/bridge chord progression that includes key changes or at least it contains chords not in the key of the song! The I recordedvery basic tracks to use as a guide for recording the vocals. Usually I can sing a complete song 3 or 4 times and get enough material to comp together a pretty decent vocal track. But not this time! The key changes mess me up so bad I can't find the notes in the next section! So I had to record the verses on one track (times 3 for comping) and repeat that for the chorus and bridge. Then I stiched this Frankenstein vocal track together in my DAW and recorded and mixed in the other instruments. Out of about 12 separate tackes I was finally able to get one fairly decent vocal track.
I LOVE the lyrics and I LOVE the melody and chord progressions. But I don't love the vocal track! This was so hard I may try using Synthesizer V to redo the vocals properly. (And no, Synthesizer V is not AI; it is sampled human singers who were paid for their singing!)
Lyrics
I'm Broken February 06, 2026 https://johnstaplesmusic.com/FAWM2026/JohnStaples-ImBroken.mp3
you cannot help me my bridge was crossed I'm a ghost inside this body I'm already lost
spare me your pity concern for my health return to your castle and save yourself
too deep under water too far down the road too shattered to shoulder this heavy load fading at the crossroads waiting to explode I'm broken I'm broken
I don't even know where I'm sleeping tonight whether I will wake up to see the dawn's early light
family doesn't know me friends are all dead I have no address I'm livin' in my head
too deep under water too far down the road too shattered to shoulder this heavy load fading at the crossroads waiting to explode I'm broken I'm broken
all the walls of pretense have no place in my existence as they fall away meaning's falling too I am afraid to end it but I'm terrified to stay I just wish a storm would come along and carry me away hey hey
too deep under water too far down the road too shattered to shoulder this heavy load fading at the crossroads waiting to explode I'm broken I'm broken
ยฉ 2026 John Staples JohnStaplesMusic.com
Comments
Ooh. This is my kind of thing. Although this is awesome as-is. I would love a full on rock version. Like early Deep Purple.
Stick with your own singing. Always! I have to go to huge comping efforts with my instrument playing. Still much more rewarding than getting machine help.
I like the key changes a lot. and once you've learnt your own song.... you'll not need Frankenstein.
The composition of this song is frikkin brilliant!! I can't even conceive of those key changes that work so perfectly. That melody is haunting and beautiful. The lyrics are deeply impactful and sad. The line "I am afraid to end it, but I'm terrified to stay" is so powerful and frightening. You've captured the tortured soul of a lost person so well. It's astonishing you can project that kind of reality not having experienced it. You are the most amazing storyteller!! This song is musically fascinating, the composition works so well as it flows from one set of progressions into a totally different one and yet harmony is skillfully maintained. I was mesmerized and am each time I listen. Awesome job!! You are having an extraordinary FAWM my friend... this is a masterpiece of americana!!
Powerful piece of writing. Love the chorus. I predominantly only read the lyrics as I find the messaging easier to focus on. I also don't have enough knowledge to comment on the music, so I will leave that to others. Really enjoyed reading this. Thanks for your insights. Cheers
Harmonically really interesting, I can see how it would be difficult to sing. For a demo you've got something that works pretty well.
i wouldnt want to hear any voice on this but yours. and i listened closely but couldnt find any point at which your voice faltered. its all good so i hope you keep it as it is, even if you do an alternate version with a different vocal. its interesting how snippets of lyrics taken down in a notebook at different times can coalesce into a coherent song. i have often written songs that way and it usually results in something more compelling than a straight narrative.
This gives me a real Bowie vibe. I think itโs the chord progression and turn around into the chorus. The melody and the lyrics are great, love the vocal and the fade . Great stuff.
Very cool composition. It is interesting and the melody flows over it brilliantly. Great lyrics as well. your vocals to my ears sound great but that is a challenging vocal for sure, I think you pull it off.
Always good to push yourself sometimes! sounds a pretty complex approach! Your vocal sounds pretty good to my ear and very different, i can certainly hear the move between not obvious chords, but you carry it off pretty well. A good listen
Sad times we live in where we have to explain what is and isn't AI. People are so suspicious of anything that can't be done at a beach side bar - lol! (nod to one of my songs). I like that line "I have no address - I'm living in my head."
Surprise chord at the bottom of the cracker jack box. Collectibles.. Ha. Its cool. It weaves and just when it resolves it changes again only to sort of resolve. I think the deft melodic skills you posess keep it from running off the rails ๐
I really enjoyed the different keys; kind of like a palate-cleanser in between courses of a fancy meal. Iโm also glad to hear that I am not the only one who dices and splices projects. Sometimes mine seem more like Lego constructions by the time I get something shareable. Yours sounded great!
I love this, John! It's something I'd have fun singing (not in this key though lol). I actually really like your vocals on this one! The lyrics are soooo good and I really especially love the chorus.
Thank you so much Robin! I literally auditioned the lyrics and rough melody in all 12 keys before I found one where my vocals kinda worked for all the parts. I'd never be able to perform it live because I just can't seem to find the chorus key until I hear a bar of it and by then I've already missed the first word!
Ugh I've had songs like that, where I just cannot find the damn note before I hit the next chord change. Sometimes it helps to just go over and over that part (but not all the time lol).
I like the descending chord structure in the verse as a pointer to the doom of the narrator. Catchy chorus too. As always a great song, John. I think the vocal is fine!
Thank you Alex! I guess it is fine for FAWM certainly! ๐
This song really came together in a nice way. My most favorite part is "heavy load", where the words come quick one on the other. I can't explain it, it's just such a satisfying twist.